Continuing my journey through Anthony Jeselnik’s bookclub, the November choice was 2018 National Book Award Winner The Friend by Sigrid Nunez. Once again, this wasn’t a writer I had any familiarity with, and after reading the book I don’t feel like I’ve been missing out. 2018 must have been a very down year for literature.
That’s an absurdly harsh quip, of course, and some of it comes from self-frustration over my inability to enjoy more than a smidgeon of the novel. Because in principal the story is almost tailor-made for me. Like one of my favorite books, Gilead, The Friend has little plot; it’s all focused on character insight, and has roughly the same structure. In Gilead, an elderly pastor is writing a lengthy letter to his young son in hopes the lad will understand his father, who is likely to die before the boy reaches maturity. The Friend involves a women in her 30s or 40s journaling about (and often to) her dear friend, an older, famous writer and teacher who has committed suicide. At some point, she finds herself the custodian of the dead writer’s large dog, whose lifespan is known to be short and already suffers from arthritis. One very tepid point of tension is that she’s not allowed to have the dog in her apartment, and appears to be on a collision course with eviction, before resolving the matter in an obvious, if unethical fashion. (The same one used by roughly 1,000,000 library patrons who come into the building pushing a dog in a stroller).
It’s a discursive, somewhat rambling novel, which are also elements I tend to like. It’s somewhat philosophical (yet somehow never feels particularly insightful) and relies heavily on literary anecdotes about suicide and failure, touching on everything from Rilke to Flannery O’Connor. It’s within character of a well-educated writer to reference such things, but it increasingly felt to me like a NY writer (Nunez) signaling that her true audience is simply other NY writers and well-placed editors and critics. It also makes me wonder if Nunez had read The Department of Speculation, with it’s endless references to literary, historical and pop culture tidbits, which I also found annoying and exhausting after awhile. Nunez doesn’t do it quite as much as Offill, but maybe the similarity between the two is a reason I just didn’t like The Friend much at all.
I did appreciate the various tidbits about the writing life, and observations about perceived changes in attitudes about readers (and student writers) toward things like character flaws. But again, it felt like a writer talking to another writer in both the literal sense of the page and the larger scope of Nunez and her intended audience.
Other successful aspects of the book include discourses on the loss of pets and the passion we have for them. But again…duh? It didn’t help me that these asides were told in such flat, lifeless prose. As a means of communicating a sense of shock and numbness, I suppose it works quite well. But I found it to be a boring reading experience.
The book comes with an incredible amount of praise, including a ranking by the New York Times as one of the best 100 novels written in the 21st century. So I’m in a regretful minority that just doesn’t get the appeal.